in Houston, Texas
Dallas Independent School District's check register dropped from Web site ... and other unsolicited commentary on dallasisd.org
Mon Feb 16 18:19:34 2009 CST
7 comments
By Matt Pulle


After the Dallas Independent School District announced last summer that it had outspent its operating budget by tens of millions of dollars, administrators had a choice: be as transparent as possible in order to restore faith in the beleaguered district or close ranks and be as secretive as ever.

For those who followed the school district for any length of time, you may have guessed they'd go with option two. After all, this is a district that once threatened to report me to the authorities after I toured a school with a parent. My capital offense: I didn't sign in.

But the district has chosen more transparency, not less, on the heels of last year's crisis. District officials, including superintendent Michael Hinojosa, have spoke candidly about what happened and administrators have put key documents—even unflattering ones—about the district’s finances on its homepage. This includes a “Financial Corrective Action Plan” that serves as an unflinching guide to how the district will recover from its current fiscal mess.

The school district also puts information about its 2002 and 2008 bond programs on its homepage as well as handy tools to report fraud and abuse -- and tips on how to submit a public records request.

It’s all good, user-friendly stuff. But it could be better.

Check register, budget information

The district recently took down its online check register, which allowed the public to keep a close, micro-level watch on the system’s finances.

Spokesman Jon Dahlander says the district is working out a few kinks and that it plans to post the register soon. At issue is how DISD can make sure that none of its checks include sensitive student information.

The district could also do a better job of making basic budget information easier to find. When I recently checked the homepage, I was at a loss to find an up-to-date budget report. But Dahlander directed me to it.

First you click the “About Dallas ISD" tab on the top left corner of the page. Then you click on another link—this one titled “General Information” on the left side. Then scroll down to the bottom of the page until you see links to budget documents.

Given the district’s financial travails, the school district should just link to all that info on its homepage with a clearly marked tab.

UPDATE (10:23 p.m.): Although it's like pulling teeth to find, it does appear the school district has maintained a PDF version of check transactions, by month. We found July and September, with no luck at finding other months yet. Any of our readers know how to find the underlying URL? Post to the comments below or e-mail us at news@texaswatchdog.org.
Comments
Kent Fischer, Dallas Morning News
Tuesday, 02/17/2009 - 10:41
No need to wrestle with DISD's web page when searching for check info. The Morning News has on our site a searchable database of every district check dating back to July 2003. You can find it linked off the DISD blog page, by following the "DISD Files" link on the right column. http://dallasisdblog.dallasnews.com/
Jennifer Peebles
Tuesday, 02/17/2009 - 14:27
Mr. Fischer, Thank you so much for reading us and writing in with this very helpful link. I'm glad the News has published that database -- but I wish we folks in the press didn't have to publish such data when a government agency could do so on its own! (I've elaborated a little bit on that topic in a new blog post at http://www.texaswatchdog.org/2009/02/why-cant-government-make-its-information-accessible-to-the-public/.) Take care, Jennifer Peebles jennifer@texaswatchdog.org
Dianna Pharr
Thursday, 02/19/2009 - 21:52
Hello Jennifer, Here's the scoop: Dallas ISD (DISD) disclosed confidential student education records to the public via the check register on the Dallas ISD (DISD) site and on the Dallas Morning News (DMN) site as well. In fact, on January 22, I notified the DMN that the DISD check register posted on the newspaper's site includes confidential education records. FERPA and IDEA federal laws require that public school districts protect confidential student information from disclosure. The district has a legal responsibility to redact confidential information from the check register before disclosing it to a third party. During November 2008, I submitted a complaint to the Texas Education Agency (TEA) regarding the district's noncompliance with federal law. TEA investigated my allegations, agreed, and subsequently ordered Dallas ISD to take specific corrective action by February 16, 2009. In part, TEA directed DISD to contact DMN so that the confidential information does not remain online, and further, provide DMN with a correctly redacted copy of the check register. Unfortunately, to date, the confidential student information that by law should be protected by the Dallas ISD, remains available for public inspection on the Dallas Morning News website.
Christine Gianadda
Thursday, 02/19/2009 - 22:44
Big deal - The check register, complete with IDEA violations, is still posted on the Dallas Morning News DISD Blog. If the attorney for Dallas ISD hand over the register rife with privacy violations to a newspaper, and the newspaper refuses to take down what was given to them *by the school attorneys* well then what? Dallas ISD needs more than a good talkin' to over this one.
Jennifer Peebles
Thursday, 02/19/2009 - 23:42
Christine, Welcome to our site. Thanks for reading us and writing in. :) Take care, Jennifer Peebles jennifer@texaswatchdog.org
Dianna Pharr
Friday, 02/20/2009 - 08:19
And as we all know, there is no agency (state or federal) that will issue consequences and therefore, there is no incentive for districts to follow the law. As long as public school districts can spend our tax dollars without limit or accountability to battle our children's rights, this problem will continue and children will pay the price. More about that here: http://www.keepeanesinformed.com/58_million.htm I notified both Dallas ISD and Dallas Morning News in November 2008 and now three months later, even with TEA's intervention, the confidential information is still online. Dianna Pharr http://www.keepeanesinformed.com
Students' Advocate
Friday, 02/20/2009 - 10:07
Well, this is certainly all very interesting. I wonder how the DMN happened upon this website about the DISD check register that has been taken down to redact illegally disclosed personally-identifiable information about MINORS. What's worse, the DMN has obviously been notified about this violation, and is arrogantly ADVERTISING it's refusal to comply with privacy laws to protect MINORS, posting the link and downloading directions to this illegally disclosed information thereby furthering the violation. While the DMN may not be compelled under the same privacy laws an ISD is, is it possible they might be compelled by some sense of moral obligation and some standard of human decency, or are they no better than the ISD attorneys who disclosed this information in the first place, perhaps as some form of retalation against those families? Shame on you DMN. I wouldn't be so sure you are legally off the hook here. Your job is reporting news, not being complicit in breaking laws. You might just end up the news yourself on this issue. DISD has taken this information down. Pick your litigant: DISD, the TEA, OCR, U.S.D.of E. or the parents whose children's rights you are knowingly violating.
Tweets
RJ Woods | 29 sec
Get started with a cool web site for as low as $29.95 per month: http://bit.ly/5fcUkH
Desiree | 5 min 22 sec
http://twitpic.com/127gbz - The View from my skylight this morning #VFTC
The New York Times | 11 min 16 sec
Afghan Avalanches Kill at Least 28 http://nyti.ms/a3LUHV
Desiree | 14 min 53 sec
RT @NCADV Introduction of the International Violence Against Women Act http://bit.ly/d1qG21 #Women #Fem2
Tips, Tools, Status | 15 min 3 sec
What do you do when you make a mistake in a tweet? http://j.mp/cM4q4W
Desiree | 17 min
RT @UniteBullying Safer Internet Day - We're here 2 help!: It's Safer Internet Day today but 4 Bullying UK it's safer in... http://buk.cc/d
KRLD | 18 min 29 sec
Fires Damage Two More East Texas Churches Near Tyler Monday Night http://bit.ly/bMJ5gX
© 2010 Texas Watchdog and Use Labs. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use and Privacy Statement