in Houston, Texas
Houston ISD trustees to vote on whether to apply for $12 million magnet school grant from feds
Thursday, Apr 08, 2010, 11:35AM CST
By Lynn Walsh

The Houston ISD school board is set to vote tonight on whether to apply for a $12 million federal grant that would create or change five magnet school programs in HISD.

If HISD is awarded the grant, about 3,300 HISD students, or their parents, would have to decide whether to continue to attend the schools with the new magnet programs or transfer to other schools. HISD serves more than 200,000 students.

As the Houston Chronicle and the Houston Press have reported, the proposal to adapt Garden Oaks into a magnet school using the Montessori method has caused an uproar among some Garden Oaks parents.

Currently, there is a Montessori program for some Garden Oaks students and a traditional education model for others, a hybrid format HISD officials term a school within a school. If HISD trustees vote "yes" Thursday, and the district subsequently receives the federal grant, officials say they would put all Garden Oaks students under the Montessori format.

The 293 students enrolled in the traditional program -- less than 0.2 percent of the HISD student population -- could choose to stay at the Garden Oaks Montessori school or attend other traditional schools in the district.

Below is a table that details the number of students enrolled at three of the five schools; these schools currently have the Montessori school model and the traditional school model.

 

HISD School

Dodson Elementary

Whidby Elementary

Garden Oaks Elementary

Total enrollment

437

614

562

Montessori students

144

130

171

Non-Montessori students

293

484

391

Students on Montessori waiting list

12

25

25

School Capacity

748

572

586

SOURCES: The Friends of Montessori Garden Oaks Web site, Houston ISD

Under the district's plan, the students at Jones High and Fondren Middle would also have to choose between staying at their schools under a magnet format, or transferring to other schools. A magnet school is one that has a particular academic emphasis, such as health sciences, or follows a program like that of the International Baccalaureate foundation.

Parents at Garden Oaks are not the only ones unhappy about the plan. Trustee Larry Marshall has spoken out against the federal magnet application, calling the plan overly ambitious and cautioning the district against getting too involved with the federal government.

Trustee Paula Harris said at a board meeting last month that no matter what happens, "everyone is not going to be happy. I can't even understand why we would even consider not applying for this grant. I would hate to lose this money."

School trustees meet at 5 p.m. Thursday at the Hattie Mae White Educational Support Center, 4400 W. 18th St.


Comments
Transition
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:02PM

The plan at Garden Oaks is for TRANSITION. It is a slow, measured process over 5 years that will not “force” anyone into Montessori that is currently in a traditional class. Children enrolling in traditional Kindergarten in 2010 will be able to stay through 5th grade at GOES.

Capacity
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:03PM

Out of a capacity of 575, only 239 zoned students choose Garden Oaks’ traditional program. That is alarming, and portends a steady enrollment decline. More telling: Already 171 Montessori students attend GOES, yet there are 131 new applications for only 44 spaces this fall – plus 26 traditional GOES students who wish to enroll in Montessori.

Standardized Test
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:04PM

On standardized tests, Montessori students generally outperform traditional students at GOES. You may access this report at http://tinyurl.com/hisdmagnetgrant.

Growth
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:06PM

The Montessori Program is the heart of Garden Oaks Elementary. Since its inception, the program has quadrupled in size. Every year there is a waiting list. Montessori makes up a third of the school because its growth has been limited by budget constraints.

SUPPORT
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:06PM

Montessori parents support the entire school.

GOES Montessori parents:

≠ Contributed 2,500 volunteer hours this school year

≠ Make up the majority of active PTA Board and committee chairs

≠ Raise and contribute tens of thousands of school dollars

School Closure
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:07PM

Without Montessori at Garden Oaks, enrollment would be 373 students and the school may eventually be considered for closure. If the issue is about choice, what choice does this leave?

If this proposal slips away, what choice will there be for the hundreds of students seeking public Montessori? What choice will minority and lower income students have, those who make up much of GOES Montessori? What choice will our neighborhood’s newest families have who desire alternative public education?

Garden Oaks parent
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 12:12PM

It seems clear that middle- and low-income families want Montessori education in public schools. For the next fall school year, there are 130 kids on the waiting list for Montessori at Garden Oaks Elementary School -- clearly an indicator of the program's popularity. At HISD's only all-Montessori elementary school campus, Wilson, there are 240 children on the waiting list.

Jennifer Peebles
Thursday, 04/08/2010 - 02:24PM

Transition, Capacity, Standardized Test, Growth, Support, School Closure, Garden Oaks parent,

We appreciate all of y'all reading and taking time to post here. Hope you'll keeping doing both.

Take care,

Jennifer P.

jennifer@texaswatchdog.org

Lynn Walsh
Friday, 04/09/2010 - 09:47AM

HISD Board of Trustees voted to approve the federal magnet grant application last night at the HISD April Board meeting. Garden Oaks is included in the grant application and will be converted into a complete Montessori magnet. Thanks for reading the article and providing more insight! Lynn@TexasWatchdog.org

Tweets
Mike Villarreal | 1 min 51 sec
My new post explains how we calculate the $5.4 billion public ed cut & why some in the #txlege claim ed funding rose: http://t.co/wCYuk9Gy
KERA Public Media | 2 min 50 sec
Art&Seek: Surprise! Victory Park Officially Declared ‘No Fun’ http://t.co/NYCSWri1
Austin Statesman | 4 min 16 sec
The Livestrong Texas 4000 cyclists are getting ready for their journey from Austin to Anchorage, Alaska. http://t.co/CBIOADdh
Texas Comptroller | 6 min 35 sec
UT's John Daly explains “Championing Ideas and Influencing Others": http://t.co/TEXNa3YU #TexasEconomy
Dallas_Observer | 6 min 45 sec
"Modest" Uptick of the Whooping Cough in Dallas County http://t.co/kIY1Nnd3
CPJ | 7 min 47 sec
Mexico should investigate murder of abducted journalist - http://t.co/ibMyRZN1
© 2012 TEXAS WATCHDOG and USELABS. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use and Privacy Statement