in Houston, Texas
Third-grader wasn't violating state rules when she accepted a Jolly Rancher at school; Brazos County girl had gotten detention for possessing candy: KHOU
Saturday, May 08, 2010, 09:14PM CST
By Lynn Walsh

What do a Jolly Rancher, a pocketwatch and a birthday cake have in common?

They got students --- and then their school administrators --- in hot water, with the most recent example in Brazos County.

Just this week a third-grader there found herself sent to a week of in-school detention, KHOU reported. Her mistake? Accepting a green Jolly Rancher candy from a classmate.

Seemingly severe punishments aren't a new trend. To wit: The case of a second-grader expelled for bringing a watch to his Louisiana school and that of the third-grader expelled for bringing a birthday cake, and a knife to cut it, to her Delaware school.

"The teacher called the principal — but not before using the knife to cut and serve the cake."
The watch and knife incidents relate to zero tolerance policies, which some schools use as a deterrent to violence and drug use. The Brazos County third-grader, by wielding a sugary treat, apparently ran afoul of state nutrition rules, school officials told KHOU.

"Jack Ellis, the superintendent for Brazos Independent School District....said the school was abiding by a state guideline that banned “minimal nutrition” foods. 'Whether or not I agree with the guidelines, we have to follow the rules,' he said."

A KHOU follow-up Friday says a state official has told the school district that state rules did not require putting the child in detention.


The school superintendent had cited a policy against foods of minimal nutritional value, which state law describes in detail. Pudding is a no-no, but processed, par-fried potatoes are OK if they're not subsequently refried at the school.

 

"FMNV (Food of Minimal Nutritional Value) may not be sold or given away to students on school premises by school administrators or staff (principals, coaches, teachers, etc.), students or student groups, parents or parent groups, guest speakers, or any other person, company or organization."

Texas emphasizes that it "does not restrict what foods or beverages parents may provide for their own children's consumption."
 
Contact Lynn Walsh at 713-228-2850 or lynn@texaswatchdog.org.

 

 

Comments
RC
Sunday, 05/09/2010 - 10:23AM

"foods of minimal nutritional value" dose that all so apply to minimal education value?

Schools have become a sterile environment; no contact, no praise no ___________, fill-in the blank

Des
Monday, 05/10/2010 - 11:38AM

Texas has money for this idiotic c***???? Were all Texas school officials hatched as adults???? We used to share bubble gum that we had already half chewed. To the little girl - trust me the rest of the world is not so narrow minded, hang in there until you are a bit older then you can have the choice of sticking around and voting out the idiots or you can move to another state where school officials do not store their brains in the same place they sit.

Roycommi
Monday, 05/10/2010 - 12:27PM

It seems like a good idea that when schools need to make budget cutbacks, the idiots that this story highlights would make for the first on the chopping block. These morons are what give public education a bad name.

JJ
Monday, 05/10/2010 - 04:16PM

What has happened to common sense?

Jess
Monday, 05/10/2010 - 08:11PM

No wondering children think adults are complete idots. I think another point that we are missing is that even if this was in fact against school policy isn't the punishment a little harsh. I mean, who made the rule that a child would get in school suspension for a week along with being segregated during lunch and recess over a piece of candy? A little harsh don't you think?

Tuesday, 05/11/2010 - 12:17PM

Zero tolerance policies are put in place by people too stupid to think once in a while.

The excuse that they are to combat "drugs & violence" in schools is exposed as ignorance, once cases like this start to show up.

All of these "zero tolerance policies" should be ended and school authorities should be made to use their heads for something other than a hat rack!!

Thursday, 05/13/2010 - 01:02PM

Tweets
Hood County News | 4 min 27 sec
Light snow reported in Pecan Plantation: Brief, light snow flurries were reported in Pecan Plantation in sou... http://t.co/iQTpTGAr #fb
Mark Tapscott | 8 min 13 sec
RT @BrianGriffiths RT @colestreeper1: 55% of #CPAC attendees were under 25. Conservatism has a new name & it's "Youth." Cultivate it.
KVUE News | 9 min 10 sec
Still need a gift for Valentine's Day? You can pre-order chocolate covered strawberries from Amy's Ice Cream online! http://t.co/zAFue8ho
keyetv | 9 min 35 sec
At 7pm join our live chat during the #Grammys w/nominee #MarciaBall & Margaret Moser @texacelt from @AustinChronicle. http://t.co/5Jllhc12
Texas Tech | 10 min 45 sec
Us too, they're our favorites! RT @GodReborn_Child: Snow days at @TexasTech are the most beautiful days I've ever seen.
klrn | 13 min 12 sec
The anticipation makes the wine taste better:) RT @1337wine @klrn isn't there a bloggers entrance ;)
© 2012 TEXAS WATCHDOG and USELABS. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use and Privacy Statement