in Houston, Texas

Texas last in benefits for public employees -- but government employees’ packages still beat private sector in all but 6 states

Thursday, Mar 03, 2011, 02:40PM CST
By Mark Lisheron
punchclock

Texas ranks last in benefits for public employees.

So says USA Today, tucked in the middle of a story earlier this week that said public employees in 41 states and the District of Columbia made more in salary and benefits, on average, than private employees.

Texas was not one of them. Only public workers in Massachusetts and Georgia lagged further behind private workers than they did in Texas, according to the chart that accompanied the story.

But what about that last in benefits business?

“Last? I knew we were pretty bad off, but I didn’t know we were last,” Mike Gross, the organizing coordinator for the Texas State Employees Union, a group claiming membership of 12,000 state employees in a state that legally prohibits collective bargaining. “We’re at the bottom by almost every measure in investment in our people.”

Since the story didn’t break the numbers down into benefits and salaries, Texas Watchdog created its own database, from the same Bureau of Economic Analysis data used for the USA Today story. What the analysis proves, once again, is that without explanation and context, numbers are mischievous creatures.
 
To access the database click here.

Texas is dead last in the average benefits package given to its public employees, according to the data for 2009.

Andy Homer, director of government relations for the Texas Public Employees Association, representing 17,000 state employees, said the benefits package item was a surprise to legislators as the story made its way around the Capitol.

“I think it has helped us, not in any positive way, but to help us, maybe, avoid some of the more serious cuts,” Homer said. “I don’t think some of these people realized what the numbers were.”

But what were the numbers? The BEA says Texas ranked 51st in its benefits package for the average public worker at $10,760 a year. That is, however, considerably more than the $9,190 the average private employee receives in benefits in Texas, according to the BEA.

A public employee’s benefits package here is worth more than the average private-sector benefits package in all but Alaska, California, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Massachusetts, New Jersey and New York. Texas’ private benefits package ranks 20th among the states and D.C.

In terms of pay, public employees in Texas rank 25th with an average annual salary of $40,550, while private employees rank 14th, making on average $45,700. Considering total compensation, the $51,310 salary and benefits package puts public employees here in 30th place, while the $54,890 package for private employees ranks 14th.

When it comes to salary, private employees do better than public employees nationally, making an average of $45,660, compared to $43,850 for public employees. The median benefits package for public employees, however, is $13,930 compared to $9,600 for private employees.

Private benefits packages range from $7,060 a year in South Dakota to $12,300 in Connecticut. The highest public benefits package, $24,870, also in Connecticut, is nearly two-and-a-half times the size of Texas’.

Perhaps most remarkable is that the most pitched battle between elected officials and state employees is being carried on in Wisconsin, which ranks 33rd and below Texas in the average salary and benefits package. The benefits package, the subject of much debate in the Badger State, ranks 41st in the country. Just $890 separates the package in a state that allows employees to collectively bargain for it  from cellar dweller Texas, where they may not.

Reinforced by explanation and context, the numbers still cannot stand on their own. They are averages, and include state and local employees whose job descriptions run a broad gamut -- from medical specialists and public lawyers to janitors and service workers.

They do not take into account chronic underfunding of state health and pension plans, which would further distance the benefits numbers for public employees from their private counterparts, according to Chris Edwards, director of tax policy studies at the Cato Institute, a D.C.-based libertarian think tank.

“There is a greater degree of job stability in the public sector that must count for something,” Edwards said. “These employees simply don’t get laid off. And there is a big difference in risk between a public teacher’s pension and a private teacher’s 401(k).”

If the data were to be further dissected and a comparison made of specific job classifications such as accountant, state employees’ total compensation packages would lag behind private employees by at least 15 percent, Homer said. The Employees Association has figures to show that state employees are twice as likely to have college degrees as a comparable body of private employees.

For the taxpayer watchdog Americans for Prosperity in Austin, it isn’t the size of the public employees’ benefits package, but its advantage over that of the private sector, executive director Peggy Venable said. Texas, she said, has a lot of government employees per capita, whose benefits are shouldered by taxpayers who also contribute to their own benefits.

Taxpayers are rightfully concerned about the pension portion of those packages.

“At some point it is going to end up breaking the back of taxpayers,” Venable said. “We are placing the responsibility for today’s pensions on the next generation of taxpayers, and we can’t afford that.”

***
Contact Mark Lisheron at 512-299-2318 or mark@texaswatchdog.org.

Keep up with all the latest news from Texas Watchdog. Fan our page on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and Scribd, and fan us on YouTube. Join our network on de.licio.us, and put our RSS feed in your newsreader. We're also on MySpace, Digg, FriendFeed, NewsVine and tumblr.

Photo of punchclock by flickr user much ado about nothing, used via a Creative Commons license.
Comments
DJ
Friday, 03/04/2011 - 01:06PM

We shouldn't be giving any benefits. Pay the workers a salary, give them one or two weeks of paid vacation and a certain number of sick days/ personal days off and that's it! If the workers want a pension, let them use their own money and pay into a private retirement account like the rest of us.

CT
Friday, 03/04/2011 - 08:44PM

Public employees in Texas pay 6.5% of their paycheck towards their retirement plan, 50% of family health insurance and if they choose to put into a 401K the State has a ZERO % match.

Texas Cattle Company
Saturday, 03/05/2011 - 05:18AM

Many of my friends with different Master's and Doctor's degrees have made 5 to 10 times a year what I made as a Texas teacher. I also have friends that never went to college that have made 3-8 times what I made as a teacher in the oil and gas industries and construction. The fact that every Texas town had a school and I could live where ever I chose and my retirement would move from school to school if I moved was something I considered when I went into teaching. It certainly wasn't the pay which was 6,000 my first year in 1973. After three years of teaching I went back to college and got a Master's degree and received other certifications which helped my pay and job choices even more. There is some stability in teaching, but not nearly as much as you might think. Teachers are non renewed every year for minor and non existent problems other that a personality conflict with a supervisor or other things that don't have anything to do with the quality of the teacher.

CSCI132
Sunday, 03/06/2011 - 09:00AM

I have been an employee of the state (Texas) for 19 years. Born and raised in Austin and my family has been in Texas since before the War of Northern Aggression.

I have a Masters and earn less than I should but could do so in the private sector. I work for the state in order to have insurance for my children as I was unable to get this through private sector jobs because one child has a long term illness. I have to pay half the cost of their insurance and then co pays, deductables, and so on.

Working for the state just about evens out in the end between lesser in pay and then the benefit package.

I cannot afford to contribute to a seperate 401K and I do pay into my retirement as does the state.

The worst rumors are 10% pay reduction and make workers pay half their insurance. In my case since what I already pay for my children does not count I would have to pay an additional $300 monthly for my insurance and a 10% reduction of pay would be $6,000 a year. So between the pay reduction and insurance costs I would be out by almost $12,000 a year. That does not include the proposed increases (again) in deductables and co pays.

In such an event I would leave state service and go back to the private sector, have no insurance and just use the hospital emergency rooms for medical care.

Ironically there is no talk of reductions of any type for all the thousands of Ghost Employees that the Legislature has, usually friends and family who are classified as part time state employees but get full time benefits at no cost to themselves, in addition to nice salary. A regular state employee who is part time has to pay a proportional amout of their health benefits.

Public Workers underpaid!!
Monday, 03/07/2011 - 03:04PM

EPI debunked this whole line of thinking last year:

The data analysis in this paper, however, indicate that public employees, both state and local government, are not overpaid. Comparisons controlling for education, experience, hours of work, organizational size, gender, race, ethnicity and disability, reveal no significant overpayment but a slight undercompensation of public employees when compared to private employee compensation costs on a per hour basis. On average, full-time state and local employees are undercompensated by 3.7%, in comparison to otherwise similar private-sector workers. The public employee compensation penalty is smaller for local government employees (1.8%) than state government workers (7.6%).

LINK: http://www.epi.org/publications/entry/debunking_the_myth_of_the_overcompensated_public_employee

Video
KTRK: On Big Screens for Billionaires, Comptroller Susan Combs Silent
Related Blogs and Media
T-Squared: A New Partnership With The Washington Post When we checked in a few weeks ago to let you know that the Tribune’s relationship...
Update:20 min 58 sec
Texas Tribune
Baytown Buc-ee’s Is Here; Goodbye Mission Burrito, Hello Überrito Mexican Grill Fuller Realty Partners and Independencia Buy Sam Houston Crossing I in Northwest Houston for $26.2M [Realty News Report] Rice Village Bar...
Update:50 min 18 sec
Swamplot
Antebellum Texas judges enjoyed sweeping habeas corpus authority Grits recently opined that, over the long arc of history, nearly all legislative involvement in habeas corpus has been to restrict judicial...
Update:1 hour 54 min
Grits for Breakfast
Gaming Good Health
Update:8 hours 23 min
Houston's Clear Thinkers
Inside Intelligence: About Rick Perry... Rick Perry leaves office after 14 years as governor next month, so we asked our insiders in...
Update:15 hours 33 min
Texas Tribune
A Few Sites from the Life of Robert Ray McKeown, Fidel Castro’s Houston-Area Gunrunner With the U.S.-Cuba cold war finally melting away, it’s as good a time as ever to point out a few key sites from Fidel Castro’s...
Update:16 hours 15 min
Swamplot
New Cuba Policy Strikes Blow to Anti-Castro Lobby This screen shot taken from live video from the TN channel shows President Barack Obama, right, and Cuba’s President Raul Castro...
Update:17 hours 43 min
Open Secrets
Houston Home Listing Photo of the Day: The Glossary 11626 Brookspring Dr. [HAR] … Read...
Update:18 hours 20 min
Swamplot
Jeb Bush’s Rivals Already Running Sens. Rand Paul and Ted Cruz share the podium in July 2013. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak, File) Former Florida Governor and ex-First Brother...
Update:19 hours 17 min
Open Secrets
The Best Sign of the New Houston: The Official 2014 Ballot It’s a new era for Houston. And with this year’s Swamplot Awards for Houston Real Estate, we aim to identify the Best Sign of the...
Update:19 hours 35 min
Swamplot
Tweets
Karen Townsend | 2 years 4 months
"Patrick F. Kennedy is a career foreign service officer" - http://t.co/GOrCe0IS
Peter Corbett ✈ | 2 years 4 months
I'm at McCarran International Airport (LAS) w/ @almacy http://t.co/KvmId07i
KERA Public Media | 2 years 4 months
TONIGHT at 7pm on KERA TV: Presidential Debate: Learn more at PBS NewsHour. http://t.co/Z9kYdun8
PBS MediaShift | 2 years 4 months
Tech Snafus Make Bill O'Reilly/Jon Stewart 'Rumble' More of a Stumble http://t.co/4OfeBlrG (@kegill | @pbsmediashift) #rumble2012
Will Sullivan | 2 years 4 months
Great addition, been burned too much by bad subs. "Google Play Announces Free Trials For In-App Subscription Services" http://t.co/TOLgRVak
TxDOT | 2 years 4 months
I-35W/North Tarrant Express #constantcontact http://t.co/QDzrQumu
keyetv | 2 years 4 months
Serial shotgun robbers suspects arrested. http://t.co/ka8T4U9B
Karen Townsend | 2 years 4 months
Aren't State Dept career people suppose to be non-partisan? Not the political appointees, the career people. #Libya
© 2014 TEXAS WATCHDOG and USELABS. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use and Privacy Statement