in Houston, Texas
Former Lubbock police officer challenges KCBD-TV reports, says Lubbock station defamed him
Thursday, Apr 28, 2011, 02:14PM CST
By Steve Miller
police tape

A former police officer in Lubbock has sued a local TV station, claiming that KCBD-TV falsely suggested he was connected to two alleged sexual assaults.

 

The news reports by KCBD Channel 11, an NBC affiliate, were based on documents from Texas Rangers investigation into officer Darrin Opaitz, and should not have been released or published, the defamation lawsuit says. Opaitz was put on administrative leave but was never charged with a crime.

 

“KCBD negligently, and with conscious disregard of the rights the Texas Constitution bestows upon its citizens,” defamed Opaitz in stories it published and broadcast, the petition filed in the 237th District Court in Lubbock says.

 

From the 25-page complaint:

On May 10, 2009, KCBD published an entry … titled ‘Public records provide no update on suspended officer.’ ... KCBD makes a false representation in their ‘sensational’ title by referring to Opaitz as a ‘suspended’ police officer, which gives readers the impression that the Lubbock Police Department suspended Opaitz or that Opaitz was being disciplined. That is inherently false.

The suit claims that by reporting that the Texas Rangers would not confirm or deny a criminal investigation was taking place KCBD implied that Opaitz had done something wrong. The station obtained the investigation report, then published it on its web site, and implied Opaitz was guilty of a crime in its story off the report, the complaint alleges.

 

The story links have been removed from the KCBD website.

 

The station began reporting the story in April 2009, when Opaitz had already been on administrative leave for six weeks. In May, a reporter filed a public information request with the Texas Department of Public Safety seeking any reports in which Opaitz was a suspect, arrestee or person of interest. The request yielded nothing.

 

In June, according to the lawsuit, a lawyer with the department emailed a two-page document that resulted in the naming of Opaitz in a sexual assault case.

 

The complaint summarizes:

Crimes, prosecutions and related judicial proceedings are matters of legitimate public concern as a matter of law. This was not a crime, prosecution or related judicial proceeding – this was merely an accusation. ...

Opaitz’ constitutional right to privacy trumps Channel 11's claims to report news, as the information [KCBD] sought to be made public was not public information and was published in an untrue and libelous context where sensationalism and not journalism was the purpose.

Opaitz, whose state law enforcement records shows no disciplinary action, left the Lubbock Police Department in January 2010 after serving 17 years, his entire Texas law enforcement career.

 

Opaitz seeks a jury trial and up to $16 million in damages. He is represented by Lamar Treadwell II, a New Mexico-based lawyer. The defendants are represented by Lubbock attorney Bob Craig. Both declined to comment.

 

In a petition to depose filed last year, Treadwell hinted of pending legal action. Among those depositions requested was that of former Lubbock city council member John Leonard, whom Treadwell accused of providing confidential information to KCBD.

 

***

Contact Steve Miller at 832-303-9420 or stevemiller@texaswatchdog.org.


Keep up with all the latest news from Texas Watchdog. Fan our page on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and Scribd, and fan us on YouTube. Join our network on de.licio.us, and put our RSS feeds in your newsreader. We're also on MySpaceDiggFriendFeedand tumblr.


Photo of police tape by flickr user freefotouk, used via a Creative Commons license.

Comments
Gritsforbreakfast
Friday, 04/29/2011 - 01:41PM

Sounds like a frivolous suit. The officer was placed on "administrative leave," which is pretty much synonymous with "suspended" in context. While it may have been a violation for a city councilman to leak the document, once he did the station did nothing wrong in publishing it. They reported an investigation for which the officer was put on administrative leave and there was one - truth is a defense.

BTW, in non-civil service departments - which is the vast majority of departments - all this information is public record, as it should be.

Peoplerpeople
Tuesday, 09/06/2011 - 02:53AM

So he worked for the 'City', that doesn't make him better than the rest of the public. Do the crime - do the time. Anyone else would be embarrassed too!

Tweets
Karen Townsend | 1 min 11 sec
Not surprising Barack aligned up nicely w/Hollande during NATO talks on increasing spending. Socialists.
Houston News | 1 min 15 sec
Teen's online punishment goes viral http://t.co/csdx4SkS #HouNews
DallasCityHallBlog | 1 min 47 sec
Jeff West, an advocate for the arts and downtown Dallas, has died http://t.co/cV0nz4x7
Beaumont Enterprise | 1 min 54 sec
Texas dioceses sue government over birth control mandate http://t.co/oCjTyH9n #SETXNews
Karen Townsend | 1 min 55 sec
3 DEA agents under investigation for hiring hookers in Colombia - separate from Sec Service investigation.
Eric Berger | 2 min
Smart kid. RT @stevesilberman: 15 year old builds portable X-ray machine. http://t.co/hbUrRgj5 (via @smerv)
© 2012 TEXAS WATCHDOG and USELABS. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use and Privacy Statement