Houston teachers' union rep went on all-expenses-paid Costa Rica trip with trustee Larry Marshall, Rep. Borris Miles
Friday, Jun 24, 2011, 08:03AM CST
By Lynn Walsh
A representative of Houston’s largest teachers’ union went on one of the all-expense-paid trips to Costa Rica offered by Houston school system vendor state Rep. Borris Miles last year -- after a union leader says the group “didn’t want to get cut short” by the Houston school system.
Zeph Capo, an executive board member for the Houston Federation of Teachers, said he went on the trip, which Miles arranged and for which the Central American nation’s government picked up the tab.
“I went because they were potentially looking at a plan where they would ship our employees overseas to have medical stuff done,” Capo told Texas Watchdog. “So, went down there to look and see what that stuff was.”
Capo said he believes he went in April of last year and that no other Houston Independent School District trustees except for Larry Marshall were on the trip with him.
“I knew the Costa Rican government was hustling the district about this,” federation president Gayle Fallon said in an interview with Texas Watchdog. “It was like, ‘OK, I’m not takin’ the trip.’ I didn’t feel right about it. I don’t think it’s good for the president of the local (union) to ever take trips for potential vendors.” Instead, she said, she sent Capo.
An e-mail obtained by Texas Watchdog shows that Miles, a Houston Democrat, offered to take most of the HISD trustees to Costa Rica. Miles also services HISD with flood insurance and is a close friend of two HISD trustees.
In an interview with Texas Watchdog, Miles said he has offered the trip to “school boards across the state” including Dallas ISD. Miles said he “offered it to many of the representatives here in the House. I’ve offered it to union groups. To any people of influence,” and he said that by offering the trip he “didn’t do anything wrong.” (He also offered the trip to a Texas Watchdog reporter who talked with him.)
Fallon says it was Miles who approached her about the trip. “My first thing was, ‘No we don’t do that,’” she said. She said she was unsure about the offer at first, but then Miles “said, ‘Look, it’s the government of Costa Rica,’” she said. “(Miles) said, ‘They really have something that could help your teachers,’ and I said, ‘I’m not gonna do it but I’ll send one of my staffers.’”
“I don’t take trips from vendors,” Fallon said. “In fact, we have probably a stronger conflict-of-interest policy than the (Houston school) district does.” She said the union policy puts a “$50 limit” on gifts.
HISD's ethics policy allows trustees to accept "a gift or other benefit conferred on account of kinship or a personal, professional, or business relationship independent of the official status of the recipient," and says that officials can accept "food, lodging, transportation, or entertainment accepted as a guest."
Marshall, a long-time HISD board member, told the Houston Chronicle last week that he didn’t see the need to disclose the two trips because the vendor, Miles, was present on the trip. District records show an approved board agenda item from February 2011 where “Miles Insurance Agency,” the same firm owned by Miles, was awarded the district’s flood insurance contract through the National Flood Insurance Program.
Miles is also close friend of both HISD trustees president Paula Harris and trustee Carol Mims Galloway. In remarks at a school board meeting earlier this year, Harris said Miles was like a brother to her, and Miles said Galloway was like a "mother" him and had almost become his mother-in-law.
The revelation of Marshall going on the Costa Rica trip is one of many recent media stories about HISD trustees and their close relationships with district vendors. A Texas Watchdog investigation found that board president Paula Harris voted to approve $28 million in district contracts with a business owned by a close friend. Harris also told the Houston Chronicle she had taken trips with the same friend, Nicole West, including a trip to Italy this year, but paid her own way. Marshall has called the recent media coverage “blatant racism.”
“It’s too easy to get in trouble with a vendor,” Fallon said. “Even if something isn’t wrong, it sometimes looks wrong.”
Fallon defended the two trips to Costa Rica Marshall accepted from Miles, and a trip HISD Trustee Harvin Moore took to China organized by the College Board, a national education nonprofit, though she said she would have sent one of her lieutenants.
“What Larry and Harvin did...isn’t illegal, depending on their actions when they get back,” Fallon said. “And you know, that’s only if there’s no kickbacks and things like that … I, personally, if I had been offered that as a board member, I would have done the same thing that I did in my (union) office -- I’d (have) a sent a staff person...You never get in trouble sending a staff person to look at it in person. That is defensible, because then people believe you were looking it instead of ‘Oh, paid vacation time.’”
The e-mail from Miles offered each trustee the chance to bring along a guest, and wrote that the Costa Rican government would waive deductibles on "medical tourism" procedures, effectively offering the trustees and their guests deep discounts on the services. Capo said he did not bring a guest and says, “I didn’t leave the hotel other than for the hospital visits or for dinner.”
Capo said there was an “exhibit hall” set-up for him and other guests to visit but the “other big part of it was the visits” to doctor’s offices and hospitals. “You had the option of going to several different hospitals or maybe to some of the hospitals and the dental clinics and that sort of thing.”
When he got there, Capo said he realized “it was certainly a lot more than HISD there … There were people from a whole lot of organizations, coming from Houston and all over the country.”
Miles also told Texas Watchdog there were more than HISD and Houston people at the conferences. “More than 200 benefits professionals, business owners and public officials from across the U.S. have attended this conference,” Miles said in a written statement. (Read the full statement here.) “As best we can tell, the public officials number ... less than 2 percent. Which is really bad, because innovations tend to come to the public sector last.”
Connect with Texas Watchdog
Related Blogs and Media
MAY 30 / What did Abraham Lincoln say about . . .
. . . how to be a good lawyer? Sometime in the 1850s, historians say, Abraham Lincoln wrote "Notes for a Lecture on Law," addressed to...
Spring Home Listing Photo of the Day: The Spot
6815 Calumet St. [HAR]
Denny Hastert, the eclectic lobbyist
(J. Dennis Hastert Center for Economics, Government, and Public Policy)
Former House Speaker Dennis Hastert‘s (R-Ill.) indictment...
How To See Your Photos on Swamplot
Got some good flood pics you’d like to share with a wider audience? Or maybe some drier images of Houston street or strip-mall life...
Midtown Superblock in Its Flooded Mudpit Phase
So as not to sully the footwear, yesterday’s groundbreaking ceremony for a park, underground parking garage, apartments, another...
Daily Demolition Report: Knox to Ground
We come to raze houses, not to bury them.
Caly Commissary, 2417 Commerce St. 77003
31 N. Saint...
Project Brays’s Successes and Failures; Hydroelectric Power at Lake Livingston; Beatles on the Move
Tons of Debris Now Being Collected from 4,000 Flood-Damaged Buildings [Houston Public Media]
Flooded-Out Homeowners: Fix Up and Move...
DOJ civil rights chief shaped by landmark TX litigation
In the course of twenty years in Texas' criminal-justice reform movement, Grits has enjoyed the good fortune to work with a bevy of amazing...
Inside Intelligence: About that Legislative Job Rating...
For this week’s nonscientific survey of insiders in government and politics, we asked...
Twenty Eight Feet
Twenty Eight Feet: life on a little wooden boat from kevinAfraser on...
Flood Night at the Edwards Cinema Greenway Parking Garage
SUV-deprived Woodland Heights resident Mimi Swartz explains how she and her husband came to spend the very wet night of May 25th reclined...
Forensic error roundup
A few more tidbits on forensic science reform, Texas' junk science writ, new legislation clarifying its meaning, and the upcoming oral...
Comment of the Day: A Better Way To Tell If Your Home Is Going To Flood
“My neighborhood flooded in Allison in 2001, and then again on Monday night. I can’t tell you how many ‘so much for the...
A Look Around and Inside the New State Bar and Capitol Club Replacement, Now Open on the Rice Hotel’s Upper Deck
The bar taking over for Downtown’s shuttered State Bar and Lounge opened quietly yesterday. That’s pretty good timing for a...
MAY 27 / The great divide
THIS IS THE GREAT DIVIDE in the U.S. [read United States] today. It is not between blacks and whites -- or rich and poor; it is between the...
The Townhome 6-Pak Looking To Move in Behind Mount Rush Hour
What’s going on behind their backs? A closeup of the rendering for Bijan Builders’ planned Bingham Court Townhomes shows an...
Chemical safety law rewrite triggers strong reactions
Sen. Tom Udall (D-N.M.) has become a key Democratic proponent of a TSCA rewrite. (Via Flickr).
Next month the House will consider a bill to...
Daily Demolition Report: Taking Congress
Floods don’t make it easy to tear down buildings, but we manage.
2002 Congress St. 77002 (aka 2000 Congress...
Buffalo Bayou Park Debut Delayed; More Mosquitoes Are Coming; FPSF Is Still On
Death Toll from Storms Increases to 7 in Houston as Flood Waters Recede [Houston Chronicle]
Floods in Houston No Surprise, Despite...
Who killed Texas' 'ban-the-box' bill?
After a promising start in the House, "ban the box" legislation - postponing questions about criminal history until later in the hiring...
MAY 28 / Amen
"THREE BOOMER presidencies are enough," writes William Kristol. He is referring, of course, to Presidents Clinton, Bush, and Obama. Last...
Tweaking Texas' junk science habeas writ, and why the state must give more notice when it asks a judge to evict you than to kill you
Legislation codifying the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals' interpretation of Texas' junk science writ (see here and the second item here)...
Houston Home Listing Photo of the Day: The Inner Bistro
7516 Del Monte Dr. [HAR]
GOP donors use Cromnibus changes to stuff party committees’ 2016 coffers; Dem donors MIA
RNC Chairman Reince Preibus. (Flickr/Gage Skidmore).
This story was cross-posted with the Guardian.
A new loophole stuck into a budget bill...
Comment of the Day: Where’s Houston’s Real-Time Flood Map?
“Has anyone posted a map of the residential streets that flooded yesterday? I’ve seen neighborhoods mentioned wholesale, but I also...
That Place on I-45 North of Downtown Where the Cars Always Seem To Hang Out After It Floods
If you’re compiling a list of best photo spots for during or after another one of Houston’s every-dozen-years-or-so...
The Finest Flooded Cars in the AMLI 2121 Parking Garage
A resident of the bayou-side North Montrose apartments at 2121 Allen Pkwy. now known as AMLI 2121 (and formerly as the Bel Air; see the...
Houston flood 2015 photos and video
No doubt you've seen a lot of photos and video from the great Houston flood of May 2015. Whatever the name, some lost their lives while...
Daily Demolition Report: Rolled Oats
All this is yours, if you can get it before it’s hauled away.
Neighbor Food Mart, 902 Ringold St....
And then the dust cleared: First look at criminal justice reforms still standing
We find little more clarity on pending Texas criminal justice legislation this morning after the last few days of deadlines. Here are a...
Houston Floods Again; Kingwood’s Rise; How the East End Got Its Rail
State of Disaster Declared in Houston After Flooding Kills at Least 4 [Reuters]
Even in Flood-Prone Houston, 11 Inches of Rain Catches...
Less Means More in Medicine
Comment of the Day: Where the Houston Peafowl Hang
“Additional peacock groups: in the Rivercrest subdivision 77042 – approximately 1 block West of Gessner, North of Westheimer Rd.,...
MAY 29 / I, Obamus
LINGUISTS at the University of Virginia put William Jefferson Clinton at the top of their narcissism index -- my label, not theirs --...
Mary Landrieu focuses her energy on a new K Street career
(AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
Recently ousted Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.) will be following in the path of numerous former colleagues from the...
Touring Buffalo Bayou Park’s New Underwater Features from Overhead
From earlier today: A series of drone’s-eye-views from above and around Allen Pkwy., just west of Downtown, surveying from high and...
Rove’s ‘new’ group isn’t new, and that could be the point
Karl Rove and his colleagues at the dark money behemoth Crossroads GPS have a “new” 501(c)(4), and according to reports, they’re...
Elan Heights Shows Off Its 4 Floors of Apartment Flooding Insurance
Future residents of Greystar’s Elan Heights: Do not fear high water. Sure, the Skylane Central on the same White Oak Bayou-fronting...
The Crispy Remains of the House at 116 Westheimer
While much of the rest of Houston is recovering from — or still dealing with — high water after last night’s torrential...
Will Sullivan | 2 years 10 months
Great addition, been burned too much by bad subs. "Google Play Announces Free Trials For In-App Subscription Services" http://t.co/TOLgRVak
Karen Townsend | 2 years 10 months
Aren't State Dept career people suppose to be non-partisan? Not the political appointees, the career people. #Libya
Caller.com | 2 years 10 months
Scanner: Bathroom on fire in 600 block of Virginia, CC fire dept. on the way
Karen Townsend | 2 years 10 months
Consistently impressed w/raullabrador when I listen to him in Congressional hearings. #Libya
Williamson County | 2 years 10 months
Mental Health Awareness Week FREE Webinar:"Understanding Depression-How to Help You or a Loved One" Thurs,Oct 11@1pm-https