Houston teachers' union rep went on all-expenses-paid Costa Rica trip with trustee Larry Marshall, Rep. Borris Miles
Friday, Jun 24, 2011, 08:03AM CST
By Lynn Walsh
A representative of Houston’s largest teachers’ union went on one of the all-expense-paid trips to Costa Rica offered by Houston school system vendor state Rep. Borris Miles last year -- after a union leader says the group “didn’t want to get cut short” by the Houston school system.
Zeph Capo, an executive board member for the Houston Federation of Teachers, said he went on the trip, which Miles arranged and for which the Central American nation’s government picked up the tab.
“I went because they were potentially looking at a plan where they would ship our employees overseas to have medical stuff done,” Capo told Texas Watchdog. “So, went down there to look and see what that stuff was.”
Capo said he believes he went in April of last year and that no other Houston Independent School District trustees except for Larry Marshall were on the trip with him.
“I knew the Costa Rican government was hustling the district about this,” federation president Gayle Fallon said in an interview with Texas Watchdog. “It was like, ‘OK, I’m not takin’ the trip.’ I didn’t feel right about it. I don’t think it’s good for the president of the local (union) to ever take trips for potential vendors.” Instead, she said, she sent Capo.
An e-mail obtained by Texas Watchdog shows that Miles, a Houston Democrat, offered to take most of the HISD trustees to Costa Rica. Miles also services HISD with flood insurance and is a close friend of two HISD trustees.
In an interview with Texas Watchdog, Miles said he has offered the trip to “school boards across the state” including Dallas ISD. Miles said he “offered it to many of the representatives here in the House. I’ve offered it to union groups. To any people of influence,” and he said that by offering the trip he “didn’t do anything wrong.” (He also offered the trip to a Texas Watchdog reporter who talked with him.)
Fallon says it was Miles who approached her about the trip. “My first thing was, ‘No we don’t do that,’” she said. She said she was unsure about the offer at first, but then Miles “said, ‘Look, it’s the government of Costa Rica,’” she said. “(Miles) said, ‘They really have something that could help your teachers,’ and I said, ‘I’m not gonna do it but I’ll send one of my staffers.’”
“I don’t take trips from vendors,” Fallon said. “In fact, we have probably a stronger conflict-of-interest policy than the (Houston school) district does.” She said the union policy puts a “$50 limit” on gifts.
HISD's ethics policy allows trustees to accept "a gift or other benefit conferred on account of kinship or a personal, professional, or business relationship independent of the official status of the recipient," and says that officials can accept "food, lodging, transportation, or entertainment accepted as a guest."
Marshall, a long-time HISD board member, told the Houston Chronicle last week that he didn’t see the need to disclose the two trips because the vendor, Miles, was present on the trip. District records show an approved board agenda item from February 2011 where “Miles Insurance Agency,” the same firm owned by Miles, was awarded the district’s flood insurance contract through the National Flood Insurance Program.
Miles is also close friend of both HISD trustees president Paula Harris and trustee Carol Mims Galloway. In remarks at a school board meeting earlier this year, Harris said Miles was like a brother to her, and Miles said Galloway was like a "mother" him and had almost become his mother-in-law.
The revelation of Marshall going on the Costa Rica trip is one of many recent media stories about HISD trustees and their close relationships with district vendors. A Texas Watchdog investigation found that board president Paula Harris voted to approve $28 million in district contracts with a business owned by a close friend. Harris also told the Houston Chronicle she had taken trips with the same friend, Nicole West, including a trip to Italy this year, but paid her own way. Marshall has called the recent media coverage “blatant racism.”
“It’s too easy to get in trouble with a vendor,” Fallon said. “Even if something isn’t wrong, it sometimes looks wrong.”
Fallon defended the two trips to Costa Rica Marshall accepted from Miles, and a trip HISD Trustee Harvin Moore took to China organized by the College Board, a national education nonprofit, though she said she would have sent one of her lieutenants.
“What Larry and Harvin did...isn’t illegal, depending on their actions when they get back,” Fallon said. “And you know, that’s only if there’s no kickbacks and things like that … I, personally, if I had been offered that as a board member, I would have done the same thing that I did in my (union) office -- I’d (have) a sent a staff person...You never get in trouble sending a staff person to look at it in person. That is defensible, because then people believe you were looking it instead of ‘Oh, paid vacation time.’”
The e-mail from Miles offered each trustee the chance to bring along a guest, and wrote that the Costa Rican government would waive deductibles on "medical tourism" procedures, effectively offering the trustees and their guests deep discounts on the services. Capo said he did not bring a guest and says, “I didn’t leave the hotel other than for the hospital visits or for dinner.”
Capo said there was an “exhibit hall” set-up for him and other guests to visit but the “other big part of it was the visits” to doctor’s offices and hospitals. “You had the option of going to several different hospitals or maybe to some of the hospitals and the dental clinics and that sort of thing.”
When he got there, Capo said he realized “it was certainly a lot more than HISD there … There were people from a whole lot of organizations, coming from Houston and all over the country.”
Miles also told Texas Watchdog there were more than HISD and Houston people at the conferences. “More than 200 benefits professionals, business owners and public officials from across the U.S. have attended this conference,” Miles said in a written statement. (Read the full statement here.) “As best we can tell, the public officials number ... less than 2 percent. Which is really bad, because innovations tend to come to the public sector last.”
Connect with Texas Watchdog
Related Blogs and Media
The Playlist: Thursday
There was no shortage of news coming out of the Texas Capitol this week, but last Thursday was so singular that we’re going to try...
Ten of the Best Super Bowl Commercials
Houston traffic's Vikki Taylor loses cancer battle
Vikki Cummings Taylor Rosenkranz, better known as Vikki Taylor, was a fixture on KTRK abc13 and 104.1 KRBE
Sad news to...
Sneak peek of Houston and Texas Super Bowl commercials
See some Houston and Texas Super Bowl TV commercials before anyone else
If you read this blog, you probably like TV, so here is a sneak...
JANUARY 31 / "Lawfare" is a great word
IT DESCRIBES the use of law as a weapon of war. But the word cannot also be applied to domestic politics, as the use of criminal charges to...
Hey KPRC 2, where's the 'Local?'
KPRC 2 changes names and drops the 'Local'
New KPRC 2 News logo
KPRC viewer emails are flying into my inbox. Why? The "KPRC Local 2"...
If Political Contributions Predicted Super Bowl Odds, Seahawks Have the Edge
A previous Vince Lombardi trophy (Photo by NVinacco via Flickr)
If writing checks to politicians and political causes is any indicator of...
Galveston Home Listing Photo of the Day: Let’s Get This Party Started
1721 61st St. [HAR]
Comment of the Day: How Your Photos Too Can Ooze That Slick but Other-World-y Real Estate Look
“1.) Get a wide lens
2.) Shoot with a 7 stop bracket
3.) Comp exposures and tone in 8 bit
4.) Crank up to 32 floating point because...
Old Katy Home Juices Up the Joint: $300K
Down-home and modern, kicky and a bit sweet, a colorized slice of old Katy living — with a century’s-worth of...
Brand New Design for a 33-Story San Felipe Residential Tower Now Ready To Be Admired Onscreen
Are we once again entering the “mightaswell” stage in the Houston real estate lifecycle? You know — the season for...
Keystone Opponents Favored by Environmental Groups, But the Checks Were Smaller
People rally to protest the Keystone XL Pipeline in front of the White House January 28, 2015 in Washington, DC. Photo by Olivier...
JANUARY 30 / Governor Abbott just said no to . . .
. . . crony capitalism. Good on him. AUSTIN -- Gov. Greg Abbott on Thursday proposed . . . . . . abolishing Texas' controversial Emerging...
Daily Demolition Report: Henry Clay
Landing a big one in Sherwood Forest. And Dairyland is no more.
Dairyland Restaurant, 310 Cavalcade St....
Online Home Searches by Commute Time; Freedmen’s Town Bricks Dispute Goes to Mediation
Camden Property Trust CEO Says Financial Backers Now Redlining Houston Area Because of Downturn [Houston Chronicle]
$8M in Renovations of...
Defending the Rule of Law in Afghanistan
Crony power grab in Montgomery County complete; new County Judge appointed to The Woodlands RUD
In a act of political chicanery you’d think was smack dab out of Washington DC, Montgomery County Commissioners voted 4-1 on Monday...
Keystone Senate Yea Votes: Seven Times More Oil & Gas Money
Sen. John Hoeven, R-N.D., sponsor of the Keystone XL pipeline bill, right, joined by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Ky., talks...
House committee: Raise age of criminal culpability from 17-18
The Texas House Criminal Jurisprudence Committee in its interim report (pdf) recommended raising the age of criminal culpability from 17 to...
A Glassy MC2 Tiltwall Mansion in Pine Wood Estates’ First 100 Days on the Market, All at $4.99M
Which way is the view? From the balcony beneath the cantilevered section that marks the entry of the Modern mansion on nearly an acre...
Back of Richmont Square Now Erased for New Menil Drawing Institute
The back third of the Menil-owned Richmont Square Apartments has now been cleared away. Left to dispose of: a below-grade swimming pool in...
Third Ward Fans Are Throwing a Party To Destroy the Flower Man’s Toxic and Art-Filled House, and Y’All Are Invited
Where else but Houston will you ever come across a day-long urban celebration that brings together demolition, visionary art, inventive...
Inside Intelligence: About Those Handgun Laws...
With rallies touting the open carry of handguns and school vouchers bookending the week, we...
JANUARY 29 / Sowell on how central planning never works but never gives way to what does
SOME OF THE MOST SWEEPING and spectacular rhetoric of the Left occurred in 18th-century France, where the very concept of the Left...
Repeal of Medical Device Tax More Likely With Friends Across Party Lines
Minnesota Sen. Al Franken is one of the Democrats cosponsoring a repeal of the medical device tax. (AP Photo/Jim Mone)
Nearly five years...
WFAA uses iPhone to tape half-hour show
WFAA 8 Dallas shows us the future of TV: The reporter and the iPhone
If you work in TV, then you've probably heard someone say at one...
Daily Demolition Report: Twin Falls Down
Crushing blows available for any occasion, especially these:
Any Occasion Party Rental, 5702 Jessamine St. 77081...
Whistleblower lab worker punished for Houston officer's mistake
Following up on the story of errors at the Houston crime lab that led to dismissal of felony DWI charges, Houston Chronicle columnist Lisa...
Hits keep on coming for TX civil commitment program
Between a new state audit generating unfavorable stories like these:Houston Chronicle: Scathing audit paints sex offender agency in...
Renting Out the ExxonMobil Tower for Police Business; Houston’s Arts and Culture Rack Up Sales
Kimco Realty Corp. Has Acquired 64 Acres Near Grand Parkway Extension for 400K-SF Retail Power Center [Houston Business Journal]
Report: Juvie deincarceraton in Texas coincided with large crime declines
A brief note from AP previewed a report on the Texas juvenile justice system coming out today:A new study concludes that the Texas juvenile...
Where is my residence? Ask the new Montgomery County Judge
Documents obtained by yours truly indicate seven people in Montgomery County, Texas are registered to vote at the address of 501 North...
Texas saw 615 deaths in custody statewide in 2014; more than 400 at TDCJ
Because the MSM covers the death penalty so closely, one frequently sees headlines like this one - "Texas inmate set to die Wednesday gets...
Houston Home Listing Photo of the Day: The Dream Team
5509 Wipprecht St. [HAR]
K Street: Return to Normalcy, or a New Normal?
President Obama signs the farm bill last February, a likely reason for the drop in 2014 lobbying spending by certain agricultural and food...
Catch All the Angles on a $1.1 Million House on a St. George Place Corner
If you’re feeling a little tipsy as you tour this 1998 custom home on Lampasas St. in St. George Place (the Galleria-area...
The Kirby Court Apartments Have Been Emptied Out, but Hanover Says Purchase of Site for Tower Has Stalled
The end of the year marked the end of residency for all tenants of the Kirby Court Apartments. Renters of the 2-story 1949 townhouse-style...
A List of 17 Fashionable Houston Newcomers Headed for River Oaks This Year Who’ll End Up on the Other Side of the Tracks
John Lobb, Akris, Kiton, Moncler, De Boulle, Giuseppe Zanotti, Etro, Chopard, Canali, Brunello Cucinelli, Brioni, Diptyque, Bonobos,...
Opens from bad 70s TV, 80 sci-fi shows and kid television
Ahhh...the memories. From bad 70s TV, 80s sci-fi TV to kiddie shows, the opens you can't forget (or maybe you can actually.)
Will Sullivan | 2 years 6 months
Great addition, been burned too much by bad subs. "Google Play Announces Free Trials For In-App Subscription Services" http://t.co/TOLgRVak
Karen Townsend | 2 years 6 months
Aren't State Dept career people suppose to be non-partisan? Not the political appointees, the career people. #Libya
Caller.com | 2 years 6 months
Scanner: Bathroom on fire in 600 block of Virginia, CC fire dept. on the way
Karen Townsend | 2 years 6 months
Consistently impressed w/raullabrador when I listen to him in Congressional hearings. #Libya
Williamson County | 2 years 6 months
Mental Health Awareness Week FREE Webinar:"Understanding Depression-How to Help You or a Loved One" Thurs,Oct 11@1pm-https